Decision tool
Repair or Replace Car Calculator
Disclosure: this site is supported by advertising and affiliate links. We may earn a commission if you buy through a link, at no cost to you. It never changes our estimates. Read our affiliate disclosure.
Reviewed · How we calculate
Verdict: Repair it. Keeping costs $164 per month, replacing costs $550 per month.
Verdict
Repair it
Fixing the car is clearly the cheaper path, and the repair does not exceed what the car is worth.
Cost per month over 3 years
- Repair ÷ car value
- 44%
- Total over period
- $5,900 vs $19,800
- Keeping the car costs 30% of what a replacement would cost per month.
- The repair is 44% of the car’s value, comfortably below the 50% caution line.
A structured estimate from your own inputs, not financial advice. The exact rules are explained below.
How the verdict is calculated
The calculator uses two signals and shows both. Nothing is hidden behind a score.
The first is cost per month. We add the repair quote to the other repairs you expect while you keep the car, then divide by the number of months you expect to keep it. That is the true monthly cost of the "repair" path. We compare it with the monthly cost you enter for a replacement vehicle.
The second is the repair-to-value ratio: the quote divided by what the car is worth today in running condition. It does not decide the outcome on its own, but when a single repair costs more than the whole car, you are taking on more risk, if something else fails next month, you cannot get that money back by selling.
- Repair: keeping the car costs under 60% of the replacement’s monthly cost, and the repair does not exceed the car’s value.
- Replace: keeping the car costs as much or more per month than replacing it, or it costs over 60% as much and the repair exceeds the car’s value.
- Borderline: everything in between. The numbers do not settle it; condition, reliability and your cash position do.
Getting honest inputs
The verdict is only as good as what you type in. Use the private-party value of the car in running condition from a pricing guide, not what you paid or what you owe. Get a written quote rather than a phone guess, and a second quote for anything over a thousand dollars.
Be realistic about remaining life. If the engine, body and the rest of the drivetrain are healthy, a major repair on a well-kept car can reasonably buy several years. If the car is rusting, burning oil or due for more big-ticket work, shorten the horizon and raise the "other repairs" figure.
For the replacement, include the full monthly difference: the loan or lease payment plus any increase in insurance and registration. A newer car usually costs more to insure than the one you are replacing.
What the calculator cannot know
Safety and reliability matter beyond the arithmetic. A car that has left you stranded twice, or that lacks safety equipment you now want, can be worth replacing even when the math favours repair. Equally, a car you know the full history of has a value that a used replacement with an unknown past does not.
This tool gives you a structured way to think, not financial advice. If the decision involves taking on a loan that strains your budget, talk it through with someone you trust before you sign.
Related repair costs
FAQ
Frequently asked questions
What is the 50% rule for car repairs?
It is a rule of thumb that says to consider replacing a car when a single repair costs more than half of the car’s market value. It is a useful warning light, not a verdict: a repair worth 70% of a car’s value can still be far cheaper per month than a replacement with a loan payment.
Should I repair a car that is paid off?
Often, yes. A paid-off car has no monthly payment, so even a large repair spread over the years it buys is usually cheaper than a new loan. The exception is when repairs are frequent enough that their monthly average approaches a car payment.
What value should I use for my car?
Use the private-party value in running condition, what the car would sell for after the repair. A pricing guide such as Kelley Blue Book or Edmunds, or recent local listings for the same year, trim and mileage, will get you close.