Skip to content

Methodology

How every number is calculated

Most repair-cost sites show a price and ask you to trust it. We show the formula, the inputs, where each input comes from, and which ones are our own judgement.

The formula

estimate = ( parts range + labor hours × hourly labor rate ) × vehicle factor

That is the entire model. It runs twice: once with the lowest parts price and fewest labor hours, once with the highest of each, to produce a range. Parts and labor are each rounded to the nearest $5, and the total is their sum.

The same function produces every figure on the site: the calculator, the state tables, the numbers in page titles and the answers in the FAQs. A number in a paragraph cannot disagree with a number in a table.

Worked example: alternator replacement, national

Parts
$180-$550
Editorial range, aftermarket to OEM
Labor hours
1-2.5 hr
Typical: about 1.5 hr
Labor rate
$140/hr
National baseline, independent shop
Vehicle factor
×1.00
Mainstream vehicle (baseline)

( $180-$550 + 1-2.5 hr × $140 ) × 1.00

= $320 to $900

Low end = lowest parts + fewest hours. High end = highest parts + most hours. Each part rounded to the nearest $5.

The four inputs

1 · Parts range

A low and high parts cost for each of our 15 repairs on a mainstream vehicle, spanning budget aftermarket to original-equipment parts. Editorial estimate.

2 · Labor hours

The range of hours a shop typically bills, from easy-access engines to awkward ones. Editorial estimate, not a licensed labor-time guide.

3 · Hourly labor rate

National baseline of $140/hr for independent shops, multiplied by the state’s cost index ÷ 100 and rounded to $5. Dealers ×1.25, chains ×1.10. Modeled from published data. Example: California’s index is 112.6, so $140 × 1.126 ≈ $160/hr.

4 · Vehicle factor

  • Mainstream car / crossover×1.00
  • Full-size truck / large SUV×1.15
  • Japanese premium brand×1.25
  • European mainstream×1.30
  • European luxury×1.60

Editorial assumption. A few vehicle pages override it for one repair and say why.

Published sources

Every external figure used in a calculation, quoted as published.
  1. [1] U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis

    Real Personal Consumption Expenditures by State and Real Personal Income by State and Metropolitan Area, 2023, Table 2: Regional Price Parities by State

    As published:
    All-items RPP, 2023: from 86.5 (Arkansas) to 112.6 (California); United States = 100.
    How we use it:
    The state cost index. Each state’s all-items Regional Price Parity scales the national labor rate up or down.
    Retrieved:
    November 2026
  2. [2] PartsTech, as cited by AAA

    2025 PartsTech Report: State of General Auto Repair Shops in the U.S.

    As published:
    Nearly half of US auto repair shops charge between $120 and $159 per hour.
    How we use it:
    The national independent-shop labor rate. We use $140/hour, the midpoint of the most common band in the report.
    Retrieved:
    November 2026
  3. [3] AAA

    Average Mechanic Labor Rate & Repair Costs in Your State

    As published:
    Labor rates vary "from less than $100 to over $200 per hour"; dealer mechanics cost more than independents, "often by 25 percent or more".
    How we use it:
    The dealer premium (×1.25 over the independent rate) and the sanity range for hourly rates.
    Retrieved:
    November 2026

Our assumptions

These inputs are our judgement, not published statistics. We list them so you can weigh them yourself.
Assumptions used in the estimates
InputValueWhy, and how far to trust it
Parts cost rangesPer repair, low to highEditorial estimates for a mainstream vehicle, spanning budget aftermarket to OEM parts. Deliberately wide and rounded. Not taken from a parts catalog feed.
Labor hoursPer repair, low to highEditorial estimates of typical billed hours across common engine layouts. Not taken from a licensed labor-time guide; your shop’s guide will give an exact figure for your vehicle.
State labor ratesNational rate × state cost index, rounded to $5Modeled, not surveyed. General price levels are a proxy for shop rates; real rates also vary widely between cities and rural areas inside a state.
Chain shop rateIndependent rate × 1.10Our assumption that national chains price between independents and dealers. We found no reliable published figure.
Vehicle multipliers×1.00 to ×1.60 by vehicle classA coarse adjustment for the well-documented pattern that trucks, premium and European vehicles cost more to repair. One number per class cannot capture individual engines or model years.

What these estimates cannot tell you

  • They are not quotes. Only a shop that has inspected your vehicle can give you a price.
  • State rates are modeled from general price levels, not surveyed from shops. Rates within a state vary widely between metro and rural areas.
  • One factor per vehicle class cannot capture a specific engine, model year or trim.
  • Sales tax, shop-supply fees, diagnostic charges, towing and related repairs are not included.
  • Parts ranges and labor hours are reviewed by hand on a schedule, so they can lag behind fast price changes.
  • The BEA price index is for 2023, the latest year in the release we use. We cover 51 jurisdictions: the 50 states and the District of Columbia.

Updates and corrections

Data was last reviewed in November 2026. When an input changes, every page that depends on it is regenerated from the same data files, so the site cannot be half-updated.

If you believe a figure is wrong, or you have a better source, write to hello@example.com. Corrections that hold up are applied and the review date above changes.

Ready to use it? Open the repair cost calculator.